I take personal offense with the likes of R. Kelly and Chris Brown. Podcasts became the natural substitute for radio shows, on-demand, any time you want content is now the focus of many creators out there. I'll never give Spotify a penny. A free and open society cannot sustain itself if it tacitly or explicitly endorses censorship. It's very much "their" idea of what fits together etc. Spotify currently faces an internal revolt due to Joe Rogan. Silicon Valley companies have faced similar complaints about censorship. Anyway, that's what I value them for. “The whole reason we wanted to be on Spotify to reach a whole different type of people. Spotify’s censorship crisis is just one part of this emerging narrative. Do you see it as a slippery slope, as many have criticized? Joe Rogan is a big focus here for his position on the Covid pandemic and for inviting guests like Alex Jones, while it is noted that Spotify refused to start a wave of censorship “interventionism” in podcasting over this, even though Jones himself was previously banned by … Censorship laws do not protect against this type of "censorship". In a way, it already was. I think it's a weird approach to take with art. Do you think Airplane should be removed from Netflix? Using Reddit. The May agreement was “the jewel in the crown” for Spotify’s massive and systematic push into the podcasting media, and on September 1, it came into effect. I do not comprehend why Spotify has censorship. Perhaps it is hypocritical of me because I will be annoyed if I am paying for a service and they then take away something that I want to watch or listen to for a reason I do not really agree with, but life will go on for me not seeing their creations, unlike how life will go on easily for their victims. Rogan’s show is … September 1, 2020 ... “Joe is dead for me if he doesn’t respond to this,” wrote a Reddit commenter. Where will we draw the line? Rule 2 does not apply when replying to this stickied comment.. Rule 2 does apply throughout the rest of this thread.. What this means: Please keep any "meta" discussion directed at specific users, mods, or r/conspiracy in general in this comment chain only.. 17. Of course Spotify is allowed to do things that would be mismanagement in my opinion, I'm just not going to be happy about it. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Joe Rogan podcast under fire for missing episodes, Spotify ‘censorship’ New, 89 comments By Jesse Holland Sep 2, 2020, 12:03pm EDT Following Spotify’s new anti-hate policy, XXXTentacion’s manager provided a long list of artists with checkered pasts and criminal allegations that were not punished by the streaming services. Nor do I think it will scale well - this sort of intervention inevitably lead to calls for more interventions, and eventually Spotify can't afford to keep track of all the nasty things their artists do. Follow Allum Bokhari @LibertarianBlue on Twitter, and download Milo Alert! Art is a tool for expression and should be available for those who want to express themselves. Popular podcast Joe Rogan responded to reports of Spotify employees wanting to censor his podcast after recent controversies. The former 'Fear Factor' host inked a reported $100 million deal with the audio platform, a move that could make his already massive showcase a cultural sensation. Spotify’s industry liaison Troy Carter also reportedly threatened to leave the streaming service if the policy wasn’t revised. YouTube as a platform/publisher has its issues regarding censorship. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. So yes, out of context it meets the vanilla definition of the word. Read some of the other replies. That's a big difference and throwing the term censorship around does a disservice to actual censorship. American comedian Joe Rogan, whose successful podcast available on YouTube landed on Spotify on september 1st after a million-dollar deal between the Swedish audio streaming company and the American stand-up comedian. Spotify censorship. The uncensored one is still there, click on the album and there should be a "Releases" button somewhere. It would be amazing if there was some way for Spotify and this person to collaborate and provide these timestamps as meta-data on Spotify. Jimmi Page is a pedo, Sid Vicious killed someone, Chuck Berry was in jail for armed robbery. Forget you if you love a car for it’s paint job? Oh, even closer to correct, do you think Netflix should remove Amy Schumer? American comedian Joe Rogan, whose successful podcast available on YouTube landed on Spotify on september 1st after a million-dollar deal between the Swedish audio streaming company and the American stand-up comedian. https://open.spotify.com/album/2zgb2l9pexGdZkM5pGuwb9?si=4ZuwmUoIS2mSHkYPioZJiQ. (Search for your favourite curse word if you want a demonstration of that). Censorship-driven Spotify employees internally flagged the the recent Alex Jones Joe Rogan episode. ... I’m not going to be a Spotify employee, we’re going to be working with the same team, doing the exact same show. Joe Rogan’s Spotify move condemned by fans over ‘right-wing censorship’ claims. In the past, Joe Rogan has slammed YouTube for its censorship of perspectives that are widely popular with the masses, but that fringe groups pressure the platform to censor. But at what price? Joe Rogan is —Lastly— On Spotify, Censorship Hits. I am against censorship for small things such as casual bad language and nudity, but I cannot help to think "good" when a company will take action like this, for convicted, actual harmful offenders. As with all such debates, language can distort the debate. The show’s fans, however, were quick to follow Peterson’s lead and call the incident out as “censorship.” Posted by u/[deleted] 1 year ago. Close. Their music does still exist on their artist pages, of course, but no one is going to run across them in playlists anymore. The fuck?!?!?! Podcasts became the natural substitute for radio shows, on-demand, any time you want content is now the focus of many creators out there. Rogan, who has a history of denouncing social media censorship, as seen below, just found his most “controversial” episodes omitted from the Spotify platform. My personal politics have shifted over the last decade but one thing has remained constant: it is more depraved to censor somebody on a society-wide level than almost any act they could have committed to evoke the censorship. Podcasts grew to develop into the pure substitute for radio reveals, on-demand, any time you want content material materials is now the principle goal of many creators in the marketplace. Those should focus on what users will like, not what they "should" like. I believe Dent in the Moon is only available if you buy the album. But where does it end? Of course I say this on reddit: the censorship acclimatization mechanism of this generation. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Couldn't find this anywhere else, but Cardboard Castles, the album, is censored on spotify. Let people decide what they want to see or hear or read. Reddit has received a $150 million investment from Tencent, the Chinese tech giant behind WeChat and League of Legends, sparking fears of censorship from Reddit … Khabib can't fart without the several subreddit pages being about the happening, yet there's entire blocks of time where the recent spotify censorship and moderator takeover isn't on the first page? Spotify is not Uncle Sam, and vice versa. no the albums there. Company employees want him censored on the platform, but that will probably never happen. If a lot of people will hate getting R. Kelly in their playlists because of what he's done (disclosure: I have no idea what he's done), then ideally that's something the algorithm should be capable of learning on its own. My kids were outraged when it happened. I am paying to listen to a full song and that is not possible through the censorship. Of course the censorship starts with Nazis, misogynists, and other assorted bigots. Why do they get to draw the line for us? the songs are censored as in the f-word isn’t. Basically you have to search it. Do you feel that Bad or Thriller should be removed from Spotify? Spotify censorship. Reddit; E-Mail; Music streaming service Spotify initiates censorship against R. Kelly and XXXTentacion By Zac Corrigan 19 May 2018 On May 10, global music streaming platform Spotify began a … Here's a link I hope it works https://open.spotify.com/album/2zgb2l9pexGdZkM5pGuwb9?si=4ZuwmUoIS2mSHkYPioZJiQ, Do you have Explicit content blocked? The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. and if they want to zero someone for their notoriety that's their choice. ReddIt. ... Share on reddit. I wonder what you guys and gals think of this. The rise of censorship on platforms like Reddit and now Spotify are proving his warning right. Streaming music service Spotify appears to have restricted podcasts including Alex Jones, Gavin McInness and others from its Joe Rogan Experience catalog. That they do it for the automated lists, though (I'm assuming you mean Discover Weekly and Release Radar, not the lists like Cyclone which are as far as I know only partly automated), is not good. Editorial, not censorship. Cookies help us deliver our Services. In their own curation, I have no problem with this. Last May, podcasting star Joe Rogan and the audio streaming giant Spotify struck a deal worth $100 million, making his show, the Joe Rogan Experience, a Spotify exclusive. I don't want some big distributor to limit my access to it because they feel like they ought to police the arts for the public. http://www.vulture.com/2018/05/what-spotify-blacklisting-r-kelly-and-xxxtentacion-means.html. We reached more than 1 million people since January 5 through Jan. 24,” he told TheDCNF. I know that he brought out a censored version of the album so that his librarian mother could show his songs to the kids in her school but unless there's 2 versions of the album on Spotify and you're somehow listening to that one, I'm not sure. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. it is censored on the artist page, but if you search up cardboard castles on spotify you can find the uncensored version. By Cindy Harper ; ... Spotify acquired exclusivity of The Joe Rogan Experience, the world’s most popular podcast, back in May. For example, I admire Eminem's work and would love listening to it but Spotify will not allow me to truly feel what the artist is trying to express through the song (Recovery). Just because Spotify doesn’t like some of his guests does not mean they should censor him. Indeed, the term ‘censorship’ conjures up images of Goebbels,but swap the term for ‘editorial decisions’ and the issue instantly assumes a different complexion. I don't use Spotify, but as a music lover and someone who is always curious about discovering music I've never heard before, I found it interesting that [Spotify is using their algorithms to censor certain artists from playlists because of transgressions in their personal lives] (http://www.vulture.com/2018/05/what-spotify-blacklisting-r-kelly-and-xxxtentacion-means.html). This could entail a new free speech policy from the company, according to Vulture, or more censorship… Let people decide what they want to see or hear or read. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the LetsTalkMusic community. They stopped promoting them on their own platform. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. What's your opinion on where Spotify has now drawn the line? Share. I can do without it. For me, the album on his artist page is censored, but for some reason the first song of his that I added to my playlist (Legend of Hardhead Ned) Is the explicit version and I can access the whole uncensored album through that. A free and open society cannot sustain itself if it tacitly or explicitly endorses censorship. Many thought that, with the move to Spotify, Rogan would have more freedom on the platform. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Interesting to note, Tencent (a company owned by the totalitarian government of China) owns about 10% of Spotify. It should be a goal for those lists to avoid editorial opinions and meddling, in my opinion. Check your settings, his songs shouldn’t be censored, It's up for me, only Dent in the moon isn't available, maybe it's blocked in your region(?). Joe Rogan became a very wealthy man when he signed up with Spotify earlier this year. Unfortunately, in the current sociopolitical environment where such things are front and center, the word is misleading. There’s two versions. I'm not making a judgment but just wanted to hear the thoughts of people I respect (you, my fellow subredditors). They also share their timestamps on Reddit. It's super distracting but I have no other way to listen to the albums. Well, it is an evolving process, a trial and error. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. As of now, R. Kelly and XXXTentacion are blacklisted and therefore do not show up in any playlists curated by mood, genre, or algorithm. Archived. The version I have saved on Spotify is and always has been uncensored. After her Twitter rant exposing the censorship, episode #1164 was made available on Spotify. Even on this subreddit we've recently had a topic talking about the line between the art and the artist. The other available release is the uncensored one. Fans are rightfully angry about the censorship surrounding the Joe Rogan podcast. “As to the evil which results from a censorship, it is impossible to measure it, for it is impossible to tell where it ends.” – Jeremy Bentham RA shares her insights regarding The Joe Rogan Podcast and Spotify. Stimulating, in-depth music discussions aren't rare here. I am not worried about living in dystopia because Spotify does not want to promote sex offenders.I think companies should be able to choose whatever they want to promote or not, but I will definitely draw the line at owning/selling/promotion of it being illegal. The ads ran from Jan. 5 to Jan. 24, according to PragerU spokesman Craig Strazzeri. Oh, I take it back. EDIT: I just want to clarify that the use of the word "censorship" is neutral for me in this context. Podcasting is a technical method and a genre of creating and disseminating content on the internet to about as wide an audience that there is (potentially – everyone and anyone online) – but still one that has the (un)fortunate distinction of being somewhat underrated. What about James Brown or Johnny Cash? Some Macklemore songs are censored too. After a ground-breaking $100 million deal with the streaming giant, one has to wonder if Rogan has that same energy for his new bosses…or if it’s enough to shut him up. They're pieces of shit and don't deserve any of my money and/or attention, but that's my decision to make. The one on my Spotify is definitely uncensored. I'll never give Spotify a penny. Just look at all the gangster rappers and the crimes they've committed in life. Of course I say this on reddit: the censorship acclimatization mechanism of this generation. When Reddit struck a $150 million investment deal with Tencent, a Chinese tech giant, its users worried about potential censorship. for Android to be kept up to date on his latest articles. The one that shows up on the artist page is censored for some reason but if you search for the album in the search bar it provides the normal version. Does anyone know why this is or how to fix it? This is a very common complaint, although it is based on a misunderstanding, as Spotify does not censor music in any way. Couldn't find this anywhere else, but Cardboard Castles, the album, is censored on spotify. Art isn't generally known to be exclusive to morally righteous people. They also put a decent amount into reddit. It’s censored for me now. Spotify’s dilemma: Censor Joe Rogan or call his podcast free speech? Nas' Spotify Censorship Hey, so I noticed that Nas' albums on spotify have a LOT of censorship. That’s just the file that’s there I think. They are trying to opinion slide the sub into "accepting" that the spotify thing is old news. They didn't stop people from listening to these artists. Any music that has been censored was submitted like that. Is this censorship warranted, as many #MeToo activists maintain? One of the highlights of the JRE experience was a user formerly known as the Timestamps Guy . A community for people who are passionate about music. The Spotify ‘black list’ notably includes controversial right-wing figures such as Alex Jones, Gavin McInnes, and Milo Yiannopoulos. Telegram. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Joe Rogan’s Spotify Movement Condemned By Fans Over “Right-Wing Censorship” Allegations | The independent. Not a week goes by without some controversy, fake news, or attempt at censorship. It's super distracting but I have no other way to listen to the albums.